Archiving Policy

Lex Humanitas Review

1. General Principle

Lex Humanitas Review is committed to maintaining the highest standards of academic integrity, originality, transparency, and ethical scholarly publishing. The Journal considers plagiarism, misappropriation of intellectual work, undisclosed text recycling, duplicate publication, and other forms of improper reuse to constitute serious breaches of publication ethics.

All manuscripts submitted to Lex Humanitas Review must represent the authors’ original scholarly work. Where authors use the words, ideas, arguments, interpretations, data, findings, tables, figures, images, legal analyses, or other intellectual contributions of others, the source must be appropriately acknowledged through quotation, citation, attribution, and, where required, permission. The Journal applies this policy to all submissions, including research articles, review articles, case notes, legal commentaries, doctrinal analyses, comparative-law studies, book reviews, and other scholarly contributions.


2. Definition of Plagiarism

For the purposes of Lex Humanitas Review, plagiarism occurs when an author presents another person’s words, ideas, research results, arguments, data, interpretations, images, tables, figures, processes, or other intellectual contributions as the author’s own without appropriate acknowledgment.

Plagiarism may occur whether the source is:

  • published or unpublished;

  • printed or electronic;

  • written in the same language or translated from another language;

  • authored by another person or by the submitting author in an earlier work;

  • contained in a journal article, book, thesis, dissertation, conference paper, report, website, preprint, working paper, legal memorandum, research proposal, or other scholarly material.

The absence of an intention to deceive does not automatically remove the ethical problem. Authors are responsible for ensuring that all borrowed material is properly identified and attributed.


3. Forms of Plagiarism

Lex Humanitas Review recognizes that plagiarism may take several forms.

3.1. Direct or Verbatim Plagiarism

Direct plagiarism occurs when an author reproduces words, sentences, paragraphs, or substantial portions of another work without quotation marks, appropriate citation, or other clear acknowledgment.

Verbatim material may only be reproduced where:

  1. the quotation is justified by the scholarly purpose;

  2. quotation marks or block-quotation formatting are used where appropriate;

  3. the original source is accurately cited; and

  4. copyright permission is obtained where legally required.


3.2. Substantial Copying

Substantial copying occurs where an author reproduces a significant part of another work without adequate attribution. The determination of whether copying is substantial is not based solely on the number of words copied. The Journal will consider both:

  • the quantity of reproduced material; and

  • the qualitative importance of the material to the original work.

Accordingly, copying a comparatively short but distinctive argument, analytical framework, original classification, legal interpretation, or conclusion may constitute serious plagiarism even where the numerical similarity is low.


3.3. Mosaic or Patchwork Plagiarism

Mosaic plagiarism occurs where an author combines phrases, sentences, ideas, or structures from one or more sources and makes minor linguistic changes while failing to provide appropriate attribution. Changing individual words, rearranging sentences, replacing terms with synonyms, or combining passages from different sources does not transform copied material into original scholarship.


3.4. Improper Paraphrasing

Paraphrasing is acceptable only where the author genuinely expresses the source material in the author’s own formulation while preserving the meaning of the original and providing an appropriate citation. Paraphrasing becomes plagiarism when an author reproduces another scholar’s argument, structure, reasoning, interpretation, or conclusions without acknowledgment, even where the wording has been changed.


3.5. Idea Plagiarism

Plagiarism is not limited to textual copying. Presenting another person’s original idea, legal argument, theoretical model, research design, classification, interpretation, conceptual framework, or analytical approach as one’s own without attribution may constitute plagiarism. Authors must acknowledge intellectual sources that materially influenced the development of their arguments.


3.6. Data, Table, Figure, and Image Plagiarism

Authors must not reproduce or adapt data, tables, figures, charts, photographs, diagrams, maps, illustrations, or other graphical material without appropriate attribution. Where permission is required by copyright law or by the original publisher, authors are responsible for obtaining such permission before publication. Manipulation of images or figures in a manner that misrepresents the scholarly record may also constitute research misconduct and will be addressed separately under the Journal’s publication-ethics procedures.


3.7. Translation Plagiarism

Translating another author’s work from one language into another without acknowledging the original source constitutes plagiarism. Translation does not create authorship. A translated argument, passage, concept, or conclusion must be cited to the original source in the same way as material reproduced in the original language.


4. Self-Plagiarism and Text Recycling

Authors are expected to disclose and appropriately cite their relevant previously published work. Text recycling or self-plagiarism may arise where authors reuse substantial portions of their own previously published text without disclosure or citation and present the material as entirely new.

Lex Humanitas Review distinguishes between legitimate limited reuse and unethical duplicate publication. Limited textual similarity may sometimes be unavoidable, particularly in descriptions of standard methodologies, definitions, legal provisions, institutional names, or technical procedures. However, authors should minimize unnecessary verbatim reuse and cite the earlier publication when the prior work materially contributes to the new manuscript.

Substantial reuse of previously published:

  • analysis;

  • literature review;

  • findings;

  • argumentation;

  • discussion;

  • conclusions; or

  • original conceptual material

without transparent disclosure and proper citation is unacceptable. Authors must not divide substantially the same research into multiple papers merely to increase publication output where this results in misleading redundancy or fragmentation.


5. Duplicate, Redundant, and Concurrent Publication

A manuscript submitted to Lex Humanitas Review must not be simultaneously under consideration by another journal. Authors must not submit a manuscript that reproduces substantially the same research already published elsewhere unless legitimate secondary publication has been expressly disclosed and approved by the relevant journals. Duplicate or redundant publication may include:

  • publication of substantially the same manuscript in more than one journal;

  • simultaneous submission to multiple journals;

  • publication of substantially the same research with only minor changes in title, wording, organization, or analysis;

  • undisclosed republication of previously published material;

  • reuse of substantially the same findings or conclusions without transparent cross-reference.

Authors must disclose related manuscripts, preprints, conference papers, working papers, theses, dissertations, or other publications where necessary to allow the Editor to evaluate possible overlap. The existence of an academic thesis, dissertation, abstract, or preprint does not automatically constitute duplicate publication; however, authors must transparently identify relevant prior dissemination and comply with applicable journal policy.


6. Plagiarism in Legal Scholarship

Because Lex Humanitas Review publishes legal scholarship, similarity reports must be interpreted with particular care. Legal manuscripts may legitimately contain recurring material such as:

  • titles of legislation;

  • statutory provisions;

  • constitutional provisions;

  • judicial quotations;

  • treaty provisions;

  • official legal terminology;

  • conventional descriptions of legal doctrines;

  • citations;

  • case names;

  • standard methodological language.

Such similarity does not automatically constitute plagiarism where the material is properly identified, cited, and used for legitimate legal analysis. However, extensive reproduction of legislation, judgments, explanatory memoranda, official documents, or other legal sources without meaningful independent analysis may still be unsuitable for publication even where technically attributed.

Authors must clearly distinguish their own legal reasoning from:

  1. the language of primary legal authorities;

  2. the interpretations of other scholars;

  3. judicial reasoning; and

  4. institutional or governmental commentary.

Translations of legislation, judicial decisions, or scholarly legal materials should identify the original source and, where relevant, whether the translation is official or prepared by the author.


7. Similarity Screening

All submissions to Lex Humanitas Review may be screened using recognized similarity-detection software, such as iThenticate/Crossref Similarity Check or another appropriate scholarly similarity-checking system, at one or more stages of the editorial process. Similarity screening is an investigative tool and not an automatic determination of plagiarism. The Journal does not determine plagiarism solely by reference to a fixed overall similarity percentage.

A similarity score may be influenced by:

  • properly quoted passages;

  • reference lists;

  • titles of legislation and judicial decisions;

  • standard methodological phrases;

  • institutional terminology;

  • author affiliations;

  • previously disclosed material;

  • numerous small matches from unrelated sources.

Conversely, serious plagiarism may exist even when the overall similarity percentage is comparatively low.

Editors will therefore examine the similarity report qualitatively and consider:

  1. the source of the overlap;

  2. the length of the matching material;

  3. whether the material is properly cited;

  4. whether quotation marks are required;

  5. the originality of the copied material;

  6. the location of the overlap within the manuscript;

  7. whether ideas, data, or conclusions have been misappropriated;

  8. whether the overlap represents legitimate reuse, text recycling, or duplicate publication; and

  9. the overall effect of the overlap on the originality and integrity of the manuscript.

The Editor-in-Chief or designated editor retains final responsibility for determining whether identified overlap raises an ethical concern.


8. Authors’ Responsibilities

Authors submitting manuscripts to Lex Humanitas Review are responsible for ensuring that:

  • the manuscript is original;

  • all sources are accurately acknowledged;

  • direct quotations are clearly identified;

  • paraphrased materials are properly cited;

  • unpublished materials are not used without authorization where authorization is required;

  • previously published work by the authors is appropriately disclosed and cited;

  • tables, images, figures, and other third-party material are properly attributed;

  • permissions have been obtained where necessary;

  • the manuscript is not simultaneously submitted elsewhere;

  • related publications are disclosed to the Editor where overlap may reasonably be questioned; and

  • all authors have reviewed and approved the final manuscript.

Authors remain fully responsible for the originality and accuracy of their manuscripts, including where language-editing software, generative artificial intelligence, translation software, reference-management tools, or other technological assistance has been used. Use of technology does not relieve an author of responsibility for plagiarism, inaccurate attribution, fabricated citations, or misrepresentation of authorship.


9. Editorial Procedure for Suspected Plagiarism Before Publication

Where possible plagiarism is identified in a submitted manuscript, the Journal will conduct a fair and documented review.

The Editor may:

  1. review the similarity report and relevant source materials;

  2. obtain additional documentary evidence;

  3. consult another editor or qualified reviewer where necessary;

  4. contact the corresponding author in neutral language and request an explanation;

  5. request revision where the concern is minor and capable of correction;

  6. reject the manuscript where plagiarism is significant;

  7. investigate whether duplicate or redundant publication is involved; and

  8. where serious misconduct appears likely, consider contacting the authors’ institution or other appropriate authority in accordance with recognized publication-ethics procedures.

Authors will normally be given an opportunity to respond before a final finding of serious misconduct is made, except where immediate editorial action is necessary to protect the integrity of the scholarly record.


10. Minor Textual Overlap

Minor overlap may include isolated phrases, standard disciplinary terminology, conventional methodological wording, or limited passages where the underlying sources are otherwise acknowledged. Where the overlap does not amount to serious misappropriation, the Editor may require the author to:

  • rewrite the affected passage;

  • use quotation marks or block quotation;

  • provide the missing citation;

  • clarify attribution;

  • obtain necessary permission; or

  • otherwise correct the manuscript before further review.

Minor overlap does not automatically require rejection, particularly where it appears to result from an honest error and can be fully corrected without compromising the originality of the manuscript.


11. Serious Plagiarism

Serious plagiarism may include, among other things:

  • unattributed reproduction of substantial portions of another work;

  • appropriation of another author’s original arguments or findings;

  • copying of data and presenting them as original;

  • extensive translation plagiarism;

  • deliberate concealment of the source;

  • plagiarism affecting the central contribution of the manuscript;

  • substantial undisclosed reuse of previously published work;

  • duplicate publication presented as a new article;

  • repeated plagiarism after previous editorial warning.

Where serious plagiarism is established before publication, the manuscript will normally be rejected.

Where circumstances warrant, the Journal may also inform:

  • all authors;

  • the institution(s) with which the authors are affiliated;

  • another journal involved in duplicate publication;

  • the copyright holder or affected author;

  • research-funding organizations; or

  • another appropriate research-integrity authority.

Such communication will be made only where justified by the seriousness of the matter and after appropriate editorial consideration.


12. Plagiarism Identified After Publication

Allegations of plagiarism involving an article already published in Lex Humanitas Review will be investigated regardless of how much time has passed since publication.

The Journal will:

  1. assess the evidence;

  2. compare the published article with the original source;

  3. consider the nature and extent of the overlap;

  4. contact the corresponding author and, where appropriate, all co-authors;

  5. request an explanation;

  6. consult the affected author, publisher, institution, or other relevant party where necessary; and

  7. determine the appropriate correction of the scholarly record.

Depending on the seriousness of the matter, the Journal may publish:

  • a correction;

  • an editorial notice;

  • an expression of concern, where appropriate;

  • or a retraction.

A retraction may be appropriate where plagiarism or substantial unattributed overlap materially undermines the originality, reliability, or integrity of the published article. Retraction is intended primarily to correct the scholarly record, not merely to punish authors.


13. Corrections and Retractions

Where the ethical concern can be adequately remedied without invalidating the scholarly contribution, the Journal may issue a correction identifying and properly acknowledging the original source. Where plagiarism is extensive or compromises the originality or integrity of the article, retraction may be required.

Any published correction or retraction will be clearly linked to the original article and will explain the reason for the editorial action to the extent appropriate and legally permissible. The Journal will seek to preserve the transparency and integrity of the scholarly record.


14. Complaints from Third Parties

Any reader, author, reviewer, institution, or other party may report suspected plagiarism to the Editorial Office.

A complaint should, where possible, include:

  • the title and authors of the article concerned;

  • identification of the allegedly plagiarized source;

  • specific passages or material believed to overlap; and

  • supporting documentation.

The Journal will assess complaints objectively and will not presume misconduct merely because an allegation has been made.

Anonymous complaints may be considered where sufficient verifiable evidence is provided.


15. Confidentiality and Due Process

Investigations into suspected plagiarism will be handled as confidentially as reasonably possible. Information will normally be shared only with persons whose involvement is necessary for the investigation or protection of the scholarly record.

Editors will seek to:

  • avoid premature accusations;

  • communicate concerns in neutral language;

  • provide authors with a reasonable opportunity to explain;

  • assess documentary evidence fairly;

  • distinguish honest error from serious misconduct where possible; and

  • apply proportionate editorial action.

No editorial decision will be based solely on an automated similarity score.


16. Responsibility of Reviewers and Editors

Editors and peer reviewers must themselves respect the intellectual property and confidentiality of submitted manuscripts.

A reviewer or editor must not:

  • appropriate an author’s ideas;

  • use unpublished data for personal advantage;

  • disclose confidential manuscript content;

  • reproduce unpublished arguments without permission; or

  • otherwise misuse information obtained through the peer-review process.

Misappropriation of material from a confidential manuscript by an editor or reviewer will be treated as serious publication misconduct.


17. Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence

Authors remain responsible for ensuring that any text produced or modified with the assistance of generative artificial intelligence does not contain plagiarized, fabricated, inaccurately attributed, or copyrighted material used without permission.

AI-generated or AI-assisted text must not be used to conceal copying or improper paraphrasing. Authors must independently verify citations, quotations, legal authorities, factual claims, and source attribution. The Journal’s separate Artificial Intelligence Policy, where applicable, should be read together with this Plagiarism Policy.


18. Similarity Percentage Policy

Lex Humanitas Review does not treat any single similarity percentage as an automatic definition of plagiarism. A manuscript with a comparatively high similarity score may contain legitimate quotations, legal materials, bibliography, or properly cited standardized wording. A manuscript with a low score may nevertheless contain serious plagiarism where the copied material consists of a distinctive original argument, important data, findings, or conclusions.

Accordingly, the Journal evaluates the substance and context of similarity rather than relying exclusively on a numerical threshold.

The Editorial Board may use internal screening benchmarks for workflow purposes, but such benchmarks do not replace editorial judgment and do not constitute automatic findings of ethical misconduct.


19. Relationship with Citation Style

Correct citation formatting alone does not necessarily eliminate plagiarism. A source may be listed in the references while substantial passages are copied without quotation marks or appropriate attribution. Likewise, extensive paraphrasing of another author’s argument may remain ethically problematic even where a citation appears elsewhere in the paragraph. Authors are therefore required to ensure that the relationship between their own contribution and the source material is transparent to readers.

Lex Humanitas Review requires manuscripts to follow the citation style prescribed in its Author Guidelines.


20. Institutional and Ethical Framework

Lex Humanitas Review applies this policy consistently with internationally recognized principles of publication ethics, research integrity, editorial independence, transparency, and correction of the scholarly record. In handling suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, text recycling, or related misconduct, the Editor may refer to guidance issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and other internationally recognized standards of responsible scholarly publishing.


21. Editorial Decision

The Editor-in-Chief has final editorial responsibility for determining whether identified textual or intellectual overlap constitutes:

  • acceptable similarity;

  • a correctable citation problem;

  • minor plagiarism;

  • substantial plagiarism;

  • self-plagiarism or inappropriate text recycling;

  • duplicate or redundant publication; or

  • another form of publication misconduct.

Decisions will take into account the evidence, seriousness of the conduct, effect on the scholarly record, authors’ explanations, and recognized principles of publication ethics. The Journal reserves the right to reject, correct, retract, or otherwise take appropriate editorial action whenever necessary to protect the integrity of Lex Humanitas Review and the scholarly record.


22. Policy Statement

By submitting a manuscript to Lex Humanitas Review, all authors confirm that their work is original, that all sources have been appropriately acknowledged, that the manuscript does not improperly reproduce previously published or unpublished material, and that it is not simultaneously under consideration by another journal.

Submission of a manuscript constitutes acceptance of this Plagiarism Policy and authorization for the Journal to conduct appropriate originality and similarity screening as part of its editorial review.