Peace without Impunity? Negotiated Settlement and Transitional Justice during Russia’s War against Ukraine

Authors

  • Maria Mikhailovna Volodymyr Dahl East Ukrainian National University

Keywords:

Ukraine, Transitional Justice, Peace Agreement, Accountability, reparation

Abstract

Can a negotiated settlement in Ukraine stop violence without legitimising territorial acquisition by force or foreclosing justice? Drawing on doctrinal analysis of international law, institutional instruments and transitional justice scholarship, this article examines the relationship between ceasefire design, accountability, reparation and participation during ongoing aggression. It distinguishes military arrangements from territorial recognition, state responsibility from individual criminal liability and the recording of harm from enforceable compensation. The article advances a non-preclusion framework: parties may sequence implementation, but cannot by agreement confer jurisdiction on independent institutions, extinguish third-party rights or transform unlawful coercion into lawful title. Applying this framework to the International Court of Justice, International Criminal Court and Ukraine-related reparation mechanisms reveals gaps in access, adjudication and payment. An effective settlement should preserve claims, facilitate immediate protection, provide reviewable procedures for affected communities and identify credible paths to implementation. The framework establishes evaluative criteria, not a prediction of negotiated outcomes.

Downloads

Published

2026-06-02