The Aceh Flag Dispute
Normative Conflict, Symbolic Politics, and Constitutional Accommodation under Indonesia’s Asymmetric Autonomy Framework
Keywords:
Aceh, asymmetric autonomy, regional flag, qanun, Helsinki Memorandum of Understanding, constitutional reviewAbstract
The prolonged dispute over Aceh’s regional flag exposes a central difficulty of post-conflict constitutionalism: how can a state honour a negotiated commitment to territorial identity while maintaining a coherent hierarchy of law? This article examines the relationship between the 2005 Helsinki Memorandum of Understanding, Law No. 11 of 2006 on the Governing of Aceh, Government Regulation No. 77 of 2007 on Regional Symbols, and Aceh Qanun No. 3 of 2013. Employing doctrinal legal research, close textual analysis, and a contextual reading of scholarship on peace agreements and identity politics, the article challenges the conventional presentation of the controversy as a straightforward conflict between lex superior and lex specialis. Article 246(4) of the Aceh law expressly subjects implementing qanun to applicable legislation, while the 2007 regulation expressly invokes that law among its legal bases. Beyond the contested flag design, additional inconsistencies concern flag placement and ceremonial use. The Constitutional Court’s 2017 decisions on annulment of regional regulations further require a distinction between administrative supervision and judicial invalidation. The article argues that legal validity, implementability, and political legitimacy should be assessed separately. It proposes a sequenced settlement combining a published legal compatibility assessment, inclusive consultations, negotiated amendment where necessary, and access to judicial review if agreement fails. The contribution is a legally precise, peace-sensitive framework for reconciling special autonomy with national constitutional order.

















